January feels like it’s the month of obligatory self-improvement.  November and December are crammed with endless gatherings, running around to parties and performances, and barely keeping it together with all the festivities on the calendar.  Then, after a week of disorienting limbo to close out the holidays, New Year’s Day rolls around with its reboot.

There’s nothing magical about January 1st, no matter what year it is (ahem, Y2K?).  In fact, it can be beneficial to think of seasonal restarts and not just annual ones.  Yes, there’s January 1st and the whole New Year.  But spring is all about rebirth and restarting growth, so March/April is a new chance – Spring Cleaning, anyone?  The start of summer is the start of clearing out as well – consider cleaning out the school desk or locker and moving on from the academic year.  Having a summer off can also be a chance to reset and refocus.  Finally, in September, there’s always the new school year with its schedule, routine, and school supplies!

Now, while there are clear benefits to goal setting and self-improvement, there are significant negative aspects to resolutions, New Year’s or otherwise.  Many associate them with pressure, difficulty living up to expectations, disappointment, and self-criticism.  It’s not the goals themselves that are problematic, but more often the way they’re implemented.  A quick bit of online research (google “top ten new year’s resolutions”) came up with:

  • Saving money (or spending less money)
  • Eating healthier
  • Exercising more
  • Losing weight
  • Spending more time with family and friends
  • Quitting smoking
  • Reducing stress
  • Improving mental health
  • Improving work-life balance
  • Something for self-care (more on that in a subsequent blog, I promise)

So, what’s wrong with these resolutions?  On the surface, absolutely nothing.  Most people would agree that each of these intentions would help contribute to an individual improving their quality of life, potentially being healthier and happier.  However, look at the wording often used for writing out one’s goals.  The phrasing for many resolutions or intentions can exacerbate the potential pitfalls people encounter.  For example, “losing weight” is consistently one of the top New Year’s resolutions, year after year, as is “stop smoking” – both are telling the individual “Stop what you’re doing” and can be associated with a finger wag and a critical headshake.  There’s a tone of reprimand, judgement, or disappointment.  By beginning the whole process with a negatively structured intention – “stop” – one small misstep can be interpreted as a failure.  If someone wants to stop smoking but then has one cigarette, have they negated their entire effort?  No.

When wording one’s intentions, begin with the Deadman’s Rule – defining a goal to have it be something you can do better than a dead man can do.  A dead man is great at not smoking cigarettes.  But can a dead man carry a packet of nicotine gum, or taking a walk around the block instead of a cigarette break?  No.  Instead of focusing on the negative elements that you don’t want to see any longer, identify positive details that you would like to build upon.  Then, by building on those constructive pieces, you will naturally move away from the negative and replace it with adaptive and more desirable elements.

Now that the goals have been reframed using the Deadman’s Rule, the next sticking point is how these intentions are translated into actions, and then if these actions can be sustained for an extended period.

With any of the resolutions listed above, there’s a vagueness about how they each will be implemented.  What does it mean to reduce stress or to have better work-life balance?  Why does the number on the scale matter?  Consider the six basic journalistic questions:

  • Who?
  • What?
  • Where?
  • Why?
  • When?
  • How?

By defining each of these, the “news story” of the intention comes to life and the implementation of the goal becomes concrete and more likely obtained.  There is a bit of blurring or overlap between these questions, but pausing to ask each one can lead to improved clarity and more effective implementation

What is being done?  This may seem obvious – losing weight or eating healthier, isn’t that clear?  However, these resolutions are not well operationalized.  The idea is listed rather than the implementation.  Try digging deeper and defining the true target, as the articulated goal is often a superficial representation of something deeper.  Even then, the surface goal may not even be directly connected to the underlying targets.  What does it mean to be “healthy” – it’s quite abstract.  And weight goals are often arbitrarily defined, not backed by sound nutritional science, and unsustainable.  It can be quite damaging to define goals around the number on a scale – weight by itself is not an absolute measure of health and focusing narrowly on that number can result in unhealthy patterns.  Instead, define actions that lift you up toward the goal – increasing fruit and vegetable intake, trying new foods, cooking at home more often – and the impact of these efforts will be measurable.  The goal is the behavior.  The underlying target is the reduced cholesterol or the better-managed blood pressure – measures associated with improved health.  The rippling effect is that the number on the scale or the fit of your clothes may change – please consider those add-ons and not the end goals themselves.

Who is involved in this goal?  No person is an island, and no one has to undertake a journey alone.  Decide who will be involved in your team and ask if they will support you in your undertaking this new goal.  Team members can include family members, friends, therapists, professionals of all walks (medical, financial, skill-based), community forums, or support groups.  There are endless options out there and some of them will best suit you.

Where are these efforts going to take place?  This is more about being flexible and adaptive.  Wherever you are, is there an opportunity for you to engage in an effort that moves you toward your goal?  If you want to spend more time with friends and family, where could you go for an excursion?  If you are at a conference for work, where can you go for a quick break and a breath of fresh air to reduce your stress or reset your mind?

When are these efforts going to happen?  If it was easy to make these changes in your day-to-day routine, you would have done so already and there wouldn’t be the need for these intentions or resolutions.  Planning a specific time for these new efforts increases the likelihood that they will be successful – write it on the calendar and make it a repeating appointment.  Consistency and regularity improve success, so look to implement these behaviors daily, or as close to daily as possible.  It’s easier to return to the pattern if one day gets skipped because of illness or other commitments, while it’s much more difficult if it’s a week or a month that has been skipped.  Be pragmatic about this scheduling and allow for some cushion.  Waking up three hours earlier than usual might be doable for one morning or maybe two, but is the change in timing sustainable for the indefinite future?  Perhaps a 15-30 minute shift is more likely.

How will you recognize your efforts to commit to these new endeavors?  How will you know that you’ve made progress?  How can you tell if these behaviors are becoming habits?  This circles back around to the underlying intentions that drive each of the target behaviors.  Check in with yourself on a regular basis and ask yourself how you’re doing.  How frequently are you engaging in these activities?  How do you feel while you’re doing them?  What is working for you?  What might you consider doing differently?  The key to successful intentions is that they are never static.  Life is constantly moving and changing, so the way we approach life must shift to keep up.

Why?  Creating change is hard to do, so why do it?  Why did one resolution make your list and not the other?  Stop and ask yourself why you are choosing this undertaking for yourself.  It’s not something you have to do; you are opting to do it – why?  It’s not something someone else is doing; you’re the one doing it – why?  So much of the time, life can feel like it’s on autopilot.  Each day is spent going through the motions because it’s what has always been done, it’s what has been expected.  For a new behavior to become established and incorporated into daily life, it helps if it resonates with who you are.  Check in with yourself and identify your more closely held values (www.viacharacter.org is a fabulous resource for this process).  How are those values reflected in your daily life?  How do your resolutions enhance these values and contribute to your daily life?  During your check-ins, remind yourself of why these new efforts are meaningful and how they are hopefully contributing to your aims.

Now that the intentions have been identified and the resolutions have been defined, what’s next?  It’s time to have fun, enjoy yourself, and see where your efforts take you.  Test things out.  See what works and what doesn’t.  These new intentions don’t have to be painful, though they may be uncomfortable.  Doing something new can feel unfamiliar and off, but it shouldn’t hurt.  The old adage of “no pain, no gain” isn’t true – pain is more likely going to lead to disengagement.

Lastly, no one is perfect, and it’s unrealistic to expect that you will be 100% successful with your efforts.  In fact, only 25% of people continue with their New Year’s resolutions beyond January!  Step back and look for what you have been able to accomplish.  Recognize those efforts.  Acknowledge the steps that you can sustain over time, because all those steps add up to reaching your goals.  New behaviors become established habits when they’ve been consistently maintained over an extended time (give or take two months).  You can expect there will be bumps in the road and unexpected challenges along the way.  If this were an easy undertaking, it would be done already.  Resolutions and behavioral changes often make the list because they are difficult to do.

Try.  Give yourself grace.  Embrace the challenge.  Believe in yourself.